To say that a dying mall can not be revived is simply not true. The Oakdale Mall (known now as Oakdale Commons) is proof of this fact. What has made its redevelopment so successful? It would appear to be a result of having an owner who actually cares about it. Many mall owners in today's world are more than happy to just let their property rot and write it off for tax purposes, but not here. Oakdale Commons went from an endangered property to one that is now thriving in my book.
First opened in 1975, it would appear that the property was once anchored by Sears, Montgomery Ward, Fowler's, Bradlee's and JCPenney. I'm uncertain if all five anchors spots were original or if some were added later. Fowler's would become Bon-Ton and Burlington Coat Factory took over the Bradlee's space. The Montgomery Ward was demolished and replaced by Kaufman's in 2000 which itself would later become Macy's.
Sears closed in 2017 and was repurposed for a brewery restaurant along with a health and fitness center. Bon-Ton would liquidate in 2018 and later be demolished for a BJ's Wholesale Club with no mall access. The Macy's space would become home to the largest Dick's House of Sport at the time of its opening. In recent years, Burlington choose to relocate outside the mall which has led to it being redeveloped for new retail and/or medical offices.
As of this post, the mall has seen substantial development occur- although the pictures featured in this post are up until major construction work began. Besides the mentioned BJ's and Dick's, the owners have brought Five Below, Five Guys, Dave & Busters and a number of new outparcels.